You recognize these “merciless” prong collars everybody whispers about on the canine park? Those that make individuals mutter about “optimistic solely” coaching?
I’ve been coaching canine for 18 years, and I’m about to inform you one thing that may shock you: I’ve seen WAY extra canine injured by common flat collars than by prong collars.
Truly, let me be extra particular—I’ve by no means seen a prong collar harm. Not as soon as. Not in 18 years and 1000’s of canine.
However trachea injury from flat collars? I see it on a regular basis.
The Physics No one Explains
Let’s discuss what truly occurs when your canine pulls on a leash.
When your 70-pound Lab launches after a squirrel carrying a flat collar, ALL that power—each single pound of it—crushes into the entrance of their neck. It’s like taking a rope and pulling it tight towards your windpipe. That concentrated strain is strictly how tracheas get broken, generally completely.
A prong collar works in another way. It distributes strain evenly across the total neck. As a substitute of 1 crushing level of strain on the windpipe, the power spreads out throughout a number of contact factors on the canine’s neck muscle tissues. It’s primary physics, however one way or the other this by no means makes it into the “prong collars are merciless” discussions.
You’ve Been Proven Propaganda
Ever seen these horrific photographs on-line of canine with wounds supposedly from prong collars? Those with captions about “torture units”?
Right here’s what these posts don’t inform you: these accidents occur when somebody leaves ANY collar on 24/7 for weeks. It’s referred to as strain necrosis—mainly mattress sores. A canine might get the identical harm from a flat collar, a harness, and even from mendacity in a single place too lengthy.
These grotesque photographs are propaganda from teams pushing to make these instruments unlawful. They know full nicely these accidents are from neglect by a human, not from the software itself. However surprising pictures get shares and donations, so the reality turns into non-obligatory.
Need to know what a canine’s neck truly seems like proper after eradicating a correctly used prong collar?
Nothing. No marks, no accidents, no drama. As a result of when used accurately, you barely want to use any strain in any respect.
The Irony That Drives Me Loopy
Folks will name prong collars “merciless” whereas their canine:
- Chokes themselves out on each stroll
- Drags them down the road like a sled canine
- Can’t go wherever as a result of they’re “too robust”
- Develops everlasting trachea injury from years of pulling
In the meantime, they’re popping ibuprofen for his or her shoulder ache and avoiding walks altogether.
That’s not humane. That’s struggling for everybody concerned—canine and human.
Right here’s What Truly Occurs
The everyday flat collar stroll:
Canine pulls → You pull again → They pull tougher → You yank → They choke and cough → Everybody’s depressing → Finally somebody will get harm
The prong collar stroll:
Canine begins to tug → Tiny correction → They instantly reply → Stroll continues peacefully → Nobody will get harm
It’s much less power wanted, no more. The prong collar truly prevents the hardcore pulling and yanking that occurs with flat collars. The canine feels the slight strain instantly and responds, as an alternative of constructing as much as a full-force pull that ends in a yanking match.
“However My Canine Doesn’t Pull That Dangerous…”
Excellent! Then they don’t want one.
That is what individuals miss—prong collars aren’t for each canine. We prepare canine each week who’ve by no means worn one and by no means will. In case your canine responds nicely to a flat collar or harness, follow what works.
However for canine who don’t care when the leash goes tight? For canine who might harm themselves or their homeowners with their pulling? For canine whose homeowners are contemplating rehoming them as a result of walks have turn into harmful?
That is security gear, not punishment.
The Instrument Doesn’t Prepare the Canine
Right here’s one thing else that must be stated: a prong collar is only a software. It’s not a magic answer. It doesn’t prepare your canine any greater than a hammer builds a home by itself.
Used incorrectly, any software could cause issues. Used accurately, as a part of correct coaching, a prong collar might be the distinction between a canine who will get walked every day and one who stays residence as a result of they’re “an excessive amount of to deal with.”
Making an Knowledgeable Determination
I’m not right here to persuade you that each canine wants a prong collar. They don’t.
However I’m right here to inform you that the black-and-white “prong collars are merciless” narrative is stopping canine and their homeowners from getting the assistance they desperately want.
If you happen to’re curious in regards to the distinction, come see for your self. We provide free evaluations the place I’ll present you precisely how these instruments work. You possibly can even really feel it by yourself arm (spoiler: it doesn’t harm—it looks like a squeeze).
Then you definitely determine what’s truly most secure to your canine.
No judgment both method. We aren’t depending on instruments to coach your canine, however when applicable, they’ll velocity up the coaching course of considerably and make it safer for everybody concerned.
Your canine deserves walks. You should take pleasure in them. Generally the “kindest” factor isn’t what it seems to be on the floor.
After 18 years of watching canine and homeowners wrestle unnecessarily, I’ve realized that actual compassion means being open to what truly works—not simply what sounds good on the canine park.
Trending Merchandise
Dog Training Collar with Remote, 4200FT Electronic Dog Shock Collar with Beep, Vibration, Shock, Light and No Shock Mode, Electric Training Collar Set for Small Medium Large Dogs (Black Green)
Jugbow Dog Shock Collar 2 Dogs – 4200FT Dog Training Collars with Remote, IPX8 Waterproof E-Collar for Dogs Training Rechargeable e-Collars for Large Medium Small Dogs (10-120lbs)
Jugbow Dog Shock Collar 2 Dogs (10-120Lbs) – 4200FT Dog Training Collar with Remote IPX7 Waterproof Electric Collar with 4 Training Modes, Security Lock, Rechargeable e-Collar for All Breeds, Sizes
Bousnic Dog Shock Collar – 3300Ft Dog Training Collar with Remote for 5-120lbs Small Medium Large Dogs Rechargeable Waterproof e Collar with Beep (1-8), Vibration(1-16), Safe Shock(1-99) (Orange)
Heavy Duty Dog Leash with 2 Handles – 6ft Reflective Anti-Pull Leash for Large Dogs, Padded Traffic Handle for Control, Durable Nylon Training Lead (Black)
